Cultural theories - some reflections


CULTURAL THEORIES – Some Reflections



phones always on silent.
I don’t like when it rings and people are calling

Kimi’s Book of Haiku, 2018



I think that the quotation from Kimi Räikkönen well supports the still prevailing stere- otypical picture of Finns that can be found also in Lewis’s book When Cultures Collide: Leading Across Cultures. Although not being able to agree to all the claims on Finns, for example, I found the book most interesting and it should be a must-read for all aspiring education exporters since it offers quite a compact but comprehensive (alt- hough in places somewhat stereotypical) picture on various cultures and their cultural traits.
When considering the cultural descriptions by Lewis(2006)1, we should be able to see which parts of the world and which countries are the most susceptible for business with Finns. For example, according to Lewis (2006, 331) the Finns have a higher de- gree of national self-consciousness than most peoples. It is a characteristic they share with the Japanese, Chinese and the French, although in some other traits they are very far from each other (c.f. Hofstede’s2 masculinity-femininity dimension).
The Finnish lack the ability or need to smooth talking - we speak little and often avoid showdowns (c.f. Kimi Räikkönen). However, according to Lewis (2006, 333) in the future, Finnish industry cannot afford to neglect any viable out-of-country markets, which also means getting on talking terms, which is difficult for the taciturn Finns. In Finland silence is not equated with failure to communicate but as an integral part of social interaction. In the Anglo-Saxon world and in Latin and Middle Eastern countries, speech is a vital tool for getting to know people and establishing a quick relationship. So, Kimi Räikkönen types may not be the best representatives for the company that desires global business.
Hofstede’s cultural dimensions theory3 consists of five dimensions along which cultural values can be analyzed: individualism-collectivism; uncertainty avoidance; power dis- tance (strength of social hierarchy) and masculinity-femininity (task orientation versus person-orientation) long-term vs. short-term orientation. In 2010, Hofstede added a sixth dimension, indulgence versus self-restraint.

1 https://moodle.hamk.fi/pluginfile.php/993291/mod_resource/content/1/TheoryLewisWhen_Cultures_Collide.PDF 2 https://geerthofstede.com/culture-geert-hofstede-gert-jan-hofstede/6d-model-of-national-culture/ (retrieved 7.10.2018)
3 https://geerthofstede.com/culture-geert-hofstede-gert-jan-hofstede/6d-model-of-national-culture/ (retrieved 7.10.2018


One of the things that strike me most, is that the majority of the theories derive from the 1970’s to early 2000. The world has changed immensely since that in a way that it has become so much “smaller”.

Wu4 (2006) has noticed that the cultural theories can get dated. Wu’s study sug- gests that work-related cultural values in a specific culture are not static and can be changed over time. When the political, societal, and economic environments change, people's cultural values also change. Thus, many cultural theories should be updated and re-evaluated periodically.

Also Michael Minkov5, for example, has published an article in 2018 in which he revis- es Hofstede’s theories. According to Minkov (2018) at the time when Hofstede deve- loped his model, and even in 2001, when his main monograph was published, the scarcity of the available data did not allow adequate large-scale tests. Yet the
world has changed enormously since then and the amount of information about cross-cultural differences worldwide has increased manifold. This wealth of infor-
mation today reveals a picture that is very different from what Hofstede extracted from his IBM data set and, apart from the fact that the Confucian societies are
now somewhat more IDV-oriented, the difference does not seem to be a result of seismic cultural restructuring across the world. It comes from the nature of Hof- stede’s IBM samples: they were not good representations of the cultures from
which they were drawn, whereas the samples available today are far more repre- sentative.

In general, for the younger generation (+/-20) the understanding of different cul- tures and intercultural communication comes very naturally. Their language skills are good and they are much more global and international than the older genera- tions. The overall understanding and knowledge of cultural literacy is growing in importance. Wood, Landry and Bloomfield (2006) state that cultural literacy in a global and multicultural world is as important as ability to read and write. Thus
also the traditional cultural theories will probably be even more shaken in the near future.


5 Michael Minkov, (2018) "A revision of Hofstede’s model of national culture: old evidence and new data from 56 countries", Cross Cultural & Strategic Management, Vol. 25 Issue: 2, pp.231-
256, https://doi.org/10.1108/CCSM-03-2017-0033 (retrieved 7.10.2018)


Those interested in intercultural communication and esp. China and Chinese, I would like to recommend professor emerita Liisa Salo-Lee’s studies.

Link to a lecture about Chinese and their culture by Liisa Salo-Lee in Finnish (also references to various cultural
https://moniviestin.jamk.fi/ohjelmat/vierailijat/kiinalainen-toimintakulttuuri/luento theories)

Another lecture from JAMK by Pasi Rutanen about business in China (in Finnish) https://moniviestin.jamk.fi/ohjelmat/lipa/liiketoiminta-ja-yrittajyys/kiinan- taloustutkimus/kiinan-liiketalous


Education for Global Responsibility

Comments

Popular Posts